Topic: Why not count thread-comment？

[escapell]

pls look here:   http://www.teikinka.com/toshiba_comments.html
my all comments is 201， but in last comment page the count displayed 193.
page 1 and 2 is ok，Because there is no thread-comment,
but page 3 not counted thread-comment.page 3 displayed 158(8 thread comments)
page 4  Calculated from 151 not159？

why？

How to make it right？

PS:my discussion  setting : Break comments into pages with 50 comments per page and the  last page displayed by default
wordpress v2.7.1

[GaMerZ]

It is not tested and not meant for threaded comments. Is it like that with the default comment navigation?

[escapell]

If I do not use your plugin the count is correct，    pls look here:  http://www.teikinka.com/2009calendar.html   

but use your plugin   and   have thread-comment the count is incorrect。

[GaMerZ]

I am referring to the default comment navi.

Code: [Select]

<div class="navigation">
<div class="alignleft"><?php previous_comments_link() ?></div>
<div class="alignright"><?php next_comments_link() ?></div>
</div> Does it display correctly?

I tested and WP does not count threaded comment as 1 for the purpose of paging.

[escapell]

YES  you said right。WP does not count threaded comment。
use default comment navi  also have that problem。

Could you make it right in your plugin？

[GaMerZ]

Nope, I still relies on WP to get me info on what the plugin need. So if WP tells me there is 3 comments in this page, means this is only 3.